3.
How Are Robots Different from Humans?
[Helena is talking to Domain, the general manager of Rossum's Universal Robots factory.]
DOMAIN: Well, any one who's looked into anatomy will have seen at once that man is too complicated, and
that a good engineer could make him more simply. So young Rossum began to overhaul anatomy and tried
to see what could be left out or simplified. In short-- but this isn't boring you,Miss Glory?
HELENA: No; on the contrary, it's awfully interesting.
DOMAIN: So young Rossum said to himself: A man is something that, for instance, feels happy, plays the
fiddle, likes going for walks, and, in fact, wants to do a whole lot of things that are really unnecessary.
HELENA: Oh!
DOMAIN:Wait a bit. That are unnecessary when he's wanted, let us say, to weave or to count. Do you play
the fiddle?
HELENA: No.
DOMAIN: That's a pity. But a working machine must not want to play the fiddle,must not feel happy,must
not do a whole lot of other things. A petrol motor must not have tassels or ornaments, Miss Glory. And to
manufacture artificial workers is the same thing as to manufacture motors. The process must be of the
simplest, and the product of the best from a practical point of view.What sort of worker do you think is the
best from a practical point of view?
HELENA: The best? Perhaps the one who is most honest and hard-working. DOMAIN: No, the cheapest.
The one whose needs are the smallest. Young Rossum invented a worker with the minimum amount of
requirements. He had to simplify him. He rejected everything that did not contribute directly to the progress
of work. In this way he rejected everything that made man more expensive. In fact, he rejected man and
made the Robot. My dear Miss Glory, the Robots are not people. Mechanically they are more perfect than
we are, they have an enormously developed intelligence, but they have no soul. Have you ever seen what a
Robot looks like inside?
HELENA: Good gracious, no!
DOMAIN: Very neat, very simple. Really a beautiful piece of work. Not much in it, but everything in flawless
order. The product of an engineer is technically at a higher pitch of perfection than a product of nature.
HELENA: Man is supposed to be the product of nature.
DOMAIN: So much the worse.
--Karel C apek,
from R.U.R. (1923, translated by P. Selver)
Based on the passage, Rossum is most likely